Subscribe to Baseball History Comes Alive! for automatic updates (sign-up block found in right side-bar)

As a Free Bonus for subscribing, you’ll get instant access to my two Special Reports: Memorable World Series Moments and Gary’s Handy Dandy World Series Reference Guide!

 Greatest Hitters of All TIme Photo Gallery
Click on any image below to see photos in full size and to start Photo Gallery:

The Greatest Hitter of All-Time

As we ponder our existence in a world without baseball, I thought it might be fun to pass some time debating something real basic: Who was the greatest hitter of all-time?

In thinking about this topic, I was reminded of an interesting article I read years ago by Dr. Thomas Sowell, a political columnist who also happened to be a huge baseball fan. Keep in mind that he wrote this column in 2012, long before the invasion of sabermetrics, so some of his conclusions may seem antiquated to us today. He narrowed his list to five candidates: Ty Cobb, Rogers Hornsby, Babe Ruth, Ted Williams, Lou Gehrig.

In broaching the subject of the all-time greatest hitter, Sowell mentioned that a lot depends on how much weight you give to batting average versus power hitting. Rather than picking and choosing excerpts from the column, I’m going to reprint it in its entirety. After reading it, follow the link to cast your vote in the poll for the greatest hitter of all-time: one of Sowell’s five candidates, or someone entirely different.

Baseball’s All-Time All-Stars

by Thomas Sowell

July 9, 2012

Nothing is likely to get an argument started among sports fans faster than attempts to name the all-time greatest in any sport, or even the all-time greatest in a particular aspect of a sport. However, in baseball, we can at least narrow down the list of possibilities — considerably, in fact — when it comes to hitting.

Who was the all-time greatest hitter?

A lot depends on how much weight you give to batting average versus power hitting. But it would be hard to consider someone for the title of the all-time greatest hitter if someone else had both a higher lifetime batting average and a higher lifetime slugging average. That narrows down the list considerably.

Ty Cobb and Rogers Hornsby

The highest lifetime batting average was Ty Cobb’s .367. But Rogers Hornsby hit .358 and, far more of a home-run hitter, Hornsby had a higher lifetime slugging average than Cobb. No one had both a higher lifetime batting average and a higher lifetime slugging average than Cobb or Hornsby. Both of them therefore belong on the short list of candidates.

Babe Ruth

Babe Ruth had by far the highest lifetime slugging average — .690. Batting averages count how many hits there are in how many official times at bat. Slugging averages count how many total bases there are from these hits — counting a single as one base and a home run as four, for example.

If you get two singles and a double every ten times at bat, then your batting average is .300, and your four total bases mean that your slugging average is .400. If you get two singles and a home run, then your six bases give you a slugging average of .600.

Babe Ruth’s lifetime slugging average of .690 means that he averaged nearly seven total bases every ten times at bat. That would mean something like a single, a double, and a home run every ten times at bat — over a span of 22 years.

Some great sluggers, in their best seasons, have had slugging averages of .700 or more, usually once or twice in a lifetime. Only two players — Babe Ruth and Barry Bonds — ever had a slugging average over .800 in a season. That’s equivalent to two singles, a double, and a home run every ten times at bat, all season long.

But if we are talking about the all-time greatest hitters, we usually mean over the course of a career, not just in a particular season when a batter was hot.

To put the Babe’s .690 lifetime slugging average in perspective, even such great sluggers as Hank Aaron, Willie Mays, Joe DiMaggio, and Hank Greenberg, in their greatest seasons, never had a slugging average as high as the .690 that Babe Ruth had for his whole career. So the Babe makes the short list.

Ted Williams

Ted Williams is best known for batting .406. What is not nearly as well known is that he had a lifetime slugging average exceeded only by Babe Ruth’s — and Williams’s lifetime batting average of .344 was two points higher than the Babe’s. So no one had both a higher lifetime batting average and a higher lifetime slugging average than Ted Williams. He too makes the short list.

Lou Gehrig

There is another important dimension to batting, the ability to come through in the clutch. This is not so easily quantifiable. However, there is one batter who stands out above all others when it comes to runs batted in — Lou Gehrig.

Despite a career shortened by the disease that bears his name, Lou Gehrig still holds the record for the most seasons with more than 150 runs batted in — seven, one out of every two full seasons in his career. Babe Ruth is second with three seasons of 150 or more runs batted in. Gehrig had 184 RBIs in 1931.

Lou Gehrig also set the lifetime record for the most home runs with the bases loaded, a record recently tied by Alex Rodriguez. Babe Ruth, Hank Aaron, and Barry Bonds, in their longer careers, hit over 200 more home runs than Gehrig, but none of the three hit as many homers with the bases loaded.

Lou Gehrig’s lifetime slugging average is third on the all-time list, just one point behind Ted Williams’s. Gehrig’s lifetime batting average of .340 is two points lower than Babe Ruth’s and four points lower than Ted Williams’s. But, if clutch hitting counts, Gehrig also belongs on the short list of all-time great batters.

We can argue about how to weigh various aspects of hitting, in order to pick the one all-time greatest batter, but at least we can narrow down the list of possibilities to five.

Shop MLB.com. The Official Online Shop of Major League Baseball.

Gary Livacari 

Photo Credits: Featured photo and other colorizations by Don Stokes; All others from Google search

Information: Article by Thomas Sowell in National Review, July 9, 2012

Check out my latest book, recently nominated for the SABR 1919 Lawrence Ritter award: Reflections On the 1919 Black Sox: Time to Take Another Look now available on Amazon in e-book and paperback. All profits go to the Illinois Veterans Foundation

Add your name to the petition to help get Gil Hodges elected to the Hall of Fame

Vote In Our New Poll: Baseball and the Coronavirus – What Constitutes a Legitimate Season? 

We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites. Click here to view Amazon’s privacy policy