Baseball History Comes Alive Now Ranked #2 by Feedspot Among All Internet Baseball History Websites and Blogs!
Guest Submissions from Our Readers Always Welcome!
Click “Home” icon on left to see display of all my articles. Follow us on Twitter: @Livac2
Visit our Facebook page: Old-Time Baseball Photos
Pete Rose Photo Gallery
Click on any image below to view entire gallery:
The Great Pete Rose: Does He Belong In the Hall of Fame?
As we’ve all heard by now, Pete Rose’s second application for reinstatement to major league baseball was denied recently by Commissioner Rob Manfred .
The first photo above shows a young Pete from early in his career, 1968.
I say let him in. That’s just my opinion, and I certainly don’t expect everyone to agree with me. No doubt Pete broke one of baseball’s cardinal rules and then lied about it for 15 years. He deserved punishment. But I think at this stage he’s suffered enough. I think his punishment should have started from the point he finally “came clean,” which was 2004. A ten-year ban seems like it would have been appropriate. It would be ending right about now.
Let’s not forget that the offense which got him banned in the first place – betting on baseball – is now a legal activity and has become a multi-million dollar industry, engaged in by tens of thousands of fans. Granted, his offense was made many times worse by the fact that he did it while in uniform, so his offense warranted significant punishment.
And let’s also not forget that we’ve still recovering from the “steroid era,” an offense which I feel is much worse than anything Pete Rose ever did. None of offenders – some of which also have lying under oath on their rap sheet – have been banned to my knowledge. Some of the worst offenders, as we know, are still playing today.
Those of us who saw him play on a regular basis will never forget the fire he brought to the game. Love him or hate him, there’s no argument he was a great player, one of the best ever. I don’t think keeping the game’s all-time hits leader out of the game for over ten years after he “came clean” is good for anyone, especially since the offense is now indulged in legally by thousands of fans.
Pete paid the price…I say let him back in.
Before you make up your mind, here’s a few highlights from the great career of “Charlie Hustle,’” Pete Rose:
Pete played in the major leagues for 24 years (1963-1986) for the Reds (1963-78), Phillies (1979-83), Expos (1984), and Reds again (1984-86). He managed the Reds from (1984-89). Over his career, Pete hit .303, with 4,256 hits (the all-time leader), 160 home runs, 746 doubles (National League record), 1,314 RBIs, 2,165 runs (National League Record), and a .375 OBP. In addition, he holds major league records for singles (3,215), games played (3,562), plate appearances (15,890), and at-bats (14,053). In 268 post-season at-bats covering 67 games, he hit .321. His 44-game hitting streak in 1978 is second all-time in the modern era to Joe DiMaggio’s 56.
Pete holds many other major league records, too numerous to list here.
Pete was a 17-time All-Star, a member of three World Series championships (1975, 1976,1980), National League Rookie of the Year (1963), three-time National League batting champion (1968, 1969, 1973), two-time Gold Glove winner (1969, 1970), Silver Slugger Award winner (1981), Roberto Clemente Award winner (1976), and a member of major league baseball All-Century team.
-Gary Livacari
Thanks for reading my post. Hope you enjoyed it! Before you leave, I hope you’ll consider:
-Viewing the other posts in my blog. Click “Home” icon on left to see display of other posts.
-Following me on any one of my social networks.
-Sharing to your favorite social media
-Leaving a comment…I love interacting with my readers!
Photo Credit: Classic Baseball Collection, by Walter Iooss, Jr; and public domain
.
Statistics from the Pete Rose Baseball-Reference page.
I grew up just south of Cincinnati during the 70’s and early 80’s. Saw him play numerous times while in his prime. I believe he should be in the HOF just based on his time of his playing days. He earned that right. But I think Shoeless Joe should go in before Rose and then Rose the following year. Shoeless Joe earned it just as much as Rose has.
i agree with sean — pete and joe jackson should have already been inducted into the h.o.f. … if we’re gonna let obvious p.e.d. users even get a sniff of the hall, these two greats have paid their dues and were among the elite … and i don’t even want to read b.b. name in print, nor r.c., the pitcher
one more thing: the h.o.f. should b for those who were great players and famous, not recipients of revisionist sabremetrics which finagle them into the hall
i admit, though, it can b REALLY tough to determine who qualifies
I think he needs to be in the Hall of Fame! Him & Johnny were what I looked up to as a kid. What about all the NFL & NCAA players making money on the side & taking ieglial drugs!?
I was a long suffering Phillies phan. Then Pete Rose came to my team. Play on the field improved immediately. Players attitudes changed, no more coasting. The ones inclined to it where afraid of Pete- they rebooted or got out of town. He was the only teammate at the time who had the clout to challenge big Michael Jack Schmidt to be not just good, but great. [ MVP 1980 World Series!] Mr. Rose almost single handedly gave Philadelphia its first baseball championship in 100 years. Too bad he bet on his own team. Strong baller- Weak will. No Hall, I’m really sorry.