Baseball History Comes Alive Now Ranked #2 by Feedspot Among All Internet Baseball History Websites and Blogs!

Guest Submissions from Our Readers Always Welcome!

Scroll Down to Read Today’s Essay

Subscribe to Baseball History Comes Alive for automatic updates. As a Free Bonus, you’ll get instant access to my Special Report: Gary’s Handy Dandy World Series Reference Guide!

1941 World Series Photo Gallery
Click on any image below to see photos in full size and to start Photo Gallery:

Yankees celebrate victory in the 1941 World Series

Spud Chandler is out at third in the second game of the 1941 World Series

Newspaper account of the 1941 World Series

Hugh Casey was one pitch away from redemption from earlier sins in the 1941 World Series

Dodgers’ lineup for the 1941 World Series: Mickey Owen, Pee Wee Reese, Cookie Lavagetto, Joe Medwick, Dolph Camilli, Pete Reiser, Billy Herman, Dixie Walker

Yankees celebrate the 1941 World Series victory

Dodger manager Leo Durocher always maintained it was the trade for Billy Herman that brought the pennant to the Dodgers in 1941

Billy Herman after his trade to the Dodgers in 1941. L-R: Billy Herman, Pete Reiser, Dolph Camilli, Dixie Walker

Leo Durocher in the dugout with a New York Yankees rival before a 1941 World Series game

Red Rolfe slides in safely in the 1941 World Series

Let’s Revisit the 1941 World Series…and the Mickey Owen Passed Ball!

With the start of the 2023 World Series just around the corner, I’ll be revisiting some of the more famous World Series from years gone by. With today being the eighty-second anniversary of one of the more infamous plays in World Series history (October 5, 1941), I’ll start with an updated chapter from my book, Memorable World Series Moments. We’ll revisit the 1941 World Series made notable by a misplay that is still talked about many years later, the Mickey Owen passed ball.

Errors and miscues are always magnified in the World Series, and they can last forever, tarnishing the reputation of even the best players. So let’s hope this year everyone plays well and there are no goats…

…As there was in 1941!

Click on link to see the composite boxscore from 1941 World Series and boxscore of individual games

Mickey Owen the “Goat” of the 1941 World Series

Mickey Owen’s passed ball in the 1941 World Series made him the goat.

“That was a tough break for Mickey to get. I bet he feels like a nickel’s worth of dog meat!” –Yankee Tommy Henrich, the beneficiary of Mickey Owen’s passed ball.

Nineteen forty-one was a great season, one of the most memorable in baseball history. It saw Ted Williams hit .406, Joe DiMaggio hit safely in 56 straight games, and the Dodgers win their first pennant since 1920.

This was also the year of the first “Subway Series” between the Dodgers and the Yankees. The two teams would meet a total of seven times from 1941 to 1956, with the Dodgers’ only victory coming in 1955. After the Dodgers departed Brooklyn for Los Angeles, the two teams met an additional four times in the Fall Classic, most recently in 1981.

In the 1941 World Series, the Dodgers faced off against Joe McCarthy’s powerful Yankee team that was loaded with star power: Joe DiMaggio, Bill Dickey, Phil Rizzuto, Red Ruffing, Lefty Gomez, Charlie “King Kong” Keller, Joe Gordon, and Tommy Henrich. Leo Durocher’s underdog Dodgers countered with stars of their own, including Billy Herman, Joe Medwick, Dolph Camilli, Pee Wee Reese, and Pete Reiser.

Unfortunately, Mickey Owen became the “goat” of the Series, committing one of the most notorious misplays in World Series history. His passed ball occurred in Game Four; and, like the Lombardi “Snooze” in 1939, it was another World Series incident with Joe DiMaggio at the center of the action.

The Yankees led the series 2-1 entering Game Four at Ebbets Field. In the top of the ninth, with the Dodgers leading 4–3, two outs, the bases empty, and a full count on Tommy Henrich, the Dodgers were one strike away from victory, one strike away from evening the series at two games apiece. Relief pitcher Hugh Casey, hoping to atone for a poor performance in Game Three, wound up and delivered a sharp breaking curve.

Henrich swung and missed! Umpire Larry Goetz raised his right hand singling “Strike Three!” The game was over!

…Or was it?

With 33,813 Flatbush faithful ready to erupt into a victory celebration, the infamous passed ball reared its ugly head. Mickey Owen chased after it all the way to the backstop. The crowd gasped – sensing disaster – as Henrich made it easily to first without a play. A great Yankee team was given a second chance, with Joe DiMaggio, no less, on deck.

AND THEN THE WHEELS CAME OFF…

As if following a script, the reliable DiMaggio kept the Yankee hopes alive with a single. Charlie Keller then delivered a clutch double to drive in both Henrich and DiMaggio, the Yankee Clipper coming all the way around from first. Suddenly, the Yankees led 5-4. But they were not yet done. Bill Dickey walked and then scored along with Keller on Joe Gordon’s double.

To the Dodger fans, it seemed like a bad dream, one of those ghastly nightmares from which there’s no escape. And yet it had happened so fast. Hardly before anyone had a chance to fully register what they had just witnessed, the score was 7-4 in favor of the Yankees. Somehow the passed ball had ignited a two-out, four-run Yankee rally.

In the bottom of the ninth, the shell-shocked Dodgers offered little resistance and meekly went down in order before the stunned Ebbets Field faithful. Instead of the Series being tied, the victory put the Yankees in the “cat-bird seat,” as Red Barber would say, one game away from a World Series victory.

It was all over but the crying for Brooklyn. Building on their momentum, the next day the Yankees easily beat the demoralized Dodgers 3-1. Just like that, the 1941 World Series was over and the Yankees were again the World Champions.

After the game, a crestfallen Mickey Owen could only lament what had just occurred. He “manned up” and put the blame squarely on himself:

“It wasn’t a strike. It was a low inside curve that I should have had. But I guess the ball struck my glove and by the time I got hold of it I couldn’t have thrown anybody out at first. It was an error.”

In the morning papers, the great sportswriter Red Smith described the reaction of the Brooklyn fans:

“Their mouths were open, their breath was indrawn for the last, exultant yell – and then ‘The Thing’ happened. Mickey Owen missed the ball, and defeat was somehow snatched from the jaws of victory.”

A great Yankee team had won the World Series for the fifth time in six years and their ninth championship overall. As for the Dodgers? They would have to wait until 1955 for a bit of revenge.

Well…all we can say is, “That’s baseball!” Let’s hope all goes well this year…with good luck to all involved, and no “goats!”

Gary Livacari

Photo Credits: All from Google search

Information: From my book, Memorable World Series Moments; and excerpts edited from the 1941 World Series Wikipedia page.

Subscribe to our website, Baseball History Comes Alive with over 1400 fully categorized baseball essays and photo galleries, now surpassing the one million hits mark with 1,100,000 hits and over 950 subscribers: https://wp.me/P7a04E-2he

Share on Facebook

Post on X

Save

7 thoughts on “Let’s Revisit the 1941 World Series…and the Mickey Owen Passed Ball!”

Thanks, Gary!

Tommy Henrich said Hugh Casey “threw the craziest curve ball I ever saw.” Not a spit ball, but one that broke so sharply he just couldn’t hold up his swing. He also said, “But I’m figuring if I’m having such a tough time maybe Owen will have trouble catching it too.”

Sure enough, Mickey couldn’t hold the pitch and the floodgates opened.

Gary Livacari says:

October 5, 2023 at 5:56 PM

Thanks Bill…Misplays in the WS are always magnified. We’re still talking about this one over 80 years later. He deserves better.

Reply

I’ve never looked it up but I clearly remember one of my “Baseball’s Greatest Games” books I had as a kid recounting that Keller “laughed of a count of two strikes” and doubled off the wall. So the Dodgers were twice in three batters “one strike away.”

And I know relief pitching wasn’t then what it is today, but with portsiders Henrich, Keller, and Dickey lurking in the 9th, maybe Leo should’ve at least had a lefty warming up?

Gary Livacari says:

October 5, 2023 at 8:28 PM

Thanks Andy…great observations.

Reply

Great account of the Owens miscue, Gary. As you said, costly errors are indeed magnified in WS play. I guess the list of those is quite long; and possibly started with the “Merkle Boner” in 1912, but I’m sure there’s others that were sooner than that. Probably the most memorable of modern times, is Buckner’s error in ’86. But there’s so many others. A coupla lesser known ones are TX Rangers Nelson Cruz’ flub in RF in 2008, the Indians Tony Fernandez’ misplayed grounder in ’97, and the Mets Daniel Murphy’s boo-boo in 2015.
Always great content in these BHCA articles. Thnx. “PLAY BALL”

Great article Gary. I was always fascinated by this World Series and the misfortune beset upon Mickey Owen. I remember reading about this World Series in one of my first baseball books. I felt so bad for Mickey Owen even though I’m a Yankee. I have also written a book about the WS and the Owen’s games is one of the chapters. Owen was the Bill Buckner of the earlier era. Let’s hope none suffers a similar fate this year.

Just getting to this now. Yes, Daniel Murphy made an error in the 2015 WS. We know he was no gold glove at second base. But the Mets “ace” closer, Familia, immediately gave up two RBI singles! Heaven forbid he should shut the door with good pitching. Like he also didn’t do in game one, remember?

Also, never mentioned, Murphy didn’t let the miscue bother him and made a really heads up play to end the inning. But that would tarnish Daniel’s image as a bad fielder.

And we all know Murphy carried the Mets on his back in the playoffs, to even get to the World Series against a better team.