Baseball History Comes Alive Now Ranked #2 by Feedspot Among All Internet Baseball History Websites and Blogs!
Guest Submissions from Our Readers Always Welcome!
Scroll Down to Read Today’s Essay
Subscribe to Baseball History Comes Alive for automatic updates. As a Free Bonus, you’ll get instant access to my Special Report: Gary’s Handy Dandy World Series Reference Guide!
“Classic Baseball Radio Broadcasters” Photo Gallery
Click on any image below to see photos in full size and to start Photo Gallery:
We welcome back Bill Schaefer today with a delightful recounting of the great marriage between AM radio and major league baseball. Any long-time fan will have no trouble grasping Bill’s theme. Sadly, as Bill points out, that marriage is undergoing severe strain. Anyone who has listened to a Cub radio broadcast in recent years knows that a once-wonderful baseball experience is becoming almost “unlistenable,” with incessant “revenue streams” marring the esthetic flow of the broadcast. Give Bill’s essay a read and I think you’ll find it interesting. -GL
IS The100-YEAR PARTNERSHIP OF AM RADIO AND BASEBALL FACING THE SAME FATE AS THE WOOLLY MAMMATH AND THE DODO?
Some consider AM stations a dying medium in the modern age of digital technology. Many automakers will be eliminating broadcast AM radio from newer models—prompting lawmakers on Capitol Hill to now propose the “AM for Every Vehicle Act.” Sure, from satellite radio and streaming services to FM stations and cellphone apps, baseball fans today have myriad options for tuning in their favorite ball clubs — even all 30 teams — whether their car features AM radio or not.
But somehow the combined DNA of AM radio and baseball in America is so powerful a link that ripping it apart in any way seems almost a form of blasphemy. Suzyn Waldman, former star of the musical stage and pioneer announcer for the New York Yankees, remembers:
“Growing up in Boston, I can still hear the Wyoming twang of Curt Gowdy. Not everyone can remember who their first television broadcasters were — but everyone knows who the radio team was. Everyone.”
Particularly for the over 50 million people in this country who have reached 65 and beyond, the memories branded on our brains are indelible…like my dad in 1951 driving our Chrysler relentlessly to the first stop, Rocky Mount, North Carolina before nightfall, on our way to Ft. Lauderdale. My mom and sister had no interest, but I was hanging on every pitch of a tense Giants game as the WMCA signal was fading fast. The crackling static was increasing by the second and I begged Dad to stop somewhere near the Delaware border to hear just one more pitch. But even though he was a great Giants fan, to my shock and disappointment, the travel schedule was more important!
The AM/baseball marriage goes back to August 5, 1921, when Harold Arlin delivered the first play-by-play of a major league game between the Phillies and Pirates at Forbes Field in Pittsburgh on KDKA. The Pirates won 8-5.
October marked the 100th anniversary of the first World Series broadcast to a national radio audience when Graham McNamee and Ford Frick were among those who called the 1923 Fall Classic between the New York Giants and Yankees on NBC.
Even though the future of AM radio is uncertain, there’s no denying its impact on the growth and popularity of baseball. “Joined at the hip,” said long-time New York Mets announcer Howie Rose, who is 69. “What AM radio has meant to baseball and vice versa is probably the quintessential symbiotic relationship.”
Those magic voices emanating from our small Philco radio absolutely grabbed me as a nine-year-old in 1947. Though riveted by the Giants in late ’46, this year the New York team had some serious sluggers. Johnny Mize, Willard Marshall, Walker Cooper, and rookie Bobby Thomson came to life with the electric radio call of Steve Ellis and Frankie Frisch.
Way past my bedtime one May night Ellis jolted my innocence, “Thomson hits a helluv…ah…heckuva drive to deep left field!” My dad and I smiled. The Fordham Flash was a little stiff, but I loved his iconic, “Oh, those bases on balls.”
Close friend, Donn Williams, and I were fascinated by Philadelphia broadcaster Byrum Saam. He was so outrageously pro Phillies it was sometimes comical. Donn’s dad had hooked up a special antenna on his radio so Donn, a diehard Dodgers fan, could hear the Brooklyn games on WMGM when the family vacationed in New Hampshire. One day in 1949, we tuned in to hear Saam on WIBG and could not believe he was screaming from the booth to get the attention of Phils’ pitcher Robin Roberts, walking off the mound after a controversial play. We heard, “Hey Robbieee! Hey Robbieee!” Oh, that AM radio again.
I interviewed Mel Allen in the mid-70s at a Hot Stove League meeting in Union, NJ. The Yankees immortal who broadcast games for seven decades, from Gehrig to Mattingly, was so nice and accommodating. Best call of a home run in baseball. And “How about that?” will live forever. The 2009 American Sportscasting Association ranked Allen the #2 Greatest Sportscaster of all time, second only to superstar announcer Vin Scully, who joined the Dodgers in 1950 and became a legend.
Sitting in the Rialto theatre in Westfield, NJ, late 40s and early 50s, there was nothing like Mel Allen doing the sports segment on Movietone News. His “Boom Box Voice” with just a touch of Alabama, reverberated through the movie house with exactly the right combination of resonance, inflection, and friendliness. Wonderful.
Mel Allen’s favorite partner, Russ Hodges, joined the Giants in 1949 and teamed with Ernie Harwell in 1950. Ernie had been with Brooklyn, and after a four-year stint with the Giants blossomed as a beloved Detroit Tigers announcer for 42 years. (Both Allen and Hodges had law degrees but never practiced law).
Russ was my favorite with a slight Tennessee intonation flavoring his play-by-play. Every kid I knew wanted the home team guy to be a fan. And Hodges conveyed his Jints allegiance with total class. His famous “The Giants win the pennant!” playoff call in ’51 [see above] was perfect under the circumstances. Red Barber said it was “unprofessional.” But anything less, after the Giants’ historic run and uber-dramatic come-from-behind victory in the ninth inning, would not have met the moment. An AM radio classic.
Official baseball historian for Major League Baseball, 76-year-old John Thorn, said,
“Some clubs resisted the advent of radio believing it would deter attendance at the game. But like the introduction of night baseball in 1935, radio had already brought big league games to the working class and especially to women.”
“Giant clear channel stations like KMOX in St. Louis with signals reaching far across the United States definitely grew the game” said Mets announcer Gary Cohen. “AM radio expanded your chance to hear about all the stars you only had in your mind.”
Harry Caray (later with the Cubs) and Jack Buck (“I do not believe what I just saw!”) brought Cardinal greats like Stan Musial, Bob Gibson and Lou Brock to life for a huge AM radio audience.
Red Barber and his refined Mississippi drawl provided folksy sayings like “He’s as cool as the other side of the pillow” and “The bases are FOB, full of Brooklyn’s” to the delight of Dodgers fans for 15 years through 1953 (most with the popular Connie Desmond) when he left to join the Yankees and Mel Allen.
There was Pittsburgh Pirates great, Bob Prince; Jack Brickhouse (primarily a fixture with the Cubs, briefly Giants ‘46); Chuck Thompson (Baltimore Orioles). And a young Ronald Reagan announcing Chicago Cubs games, in Iowa during the 1930s, by re-creating play-by-play at Wrigley Field that was originally transmitted via Morse code.
And we dare not exclude the re-creation genius, Les Keiter, (“He beat the play, he beat the play!”) who re-created San Francisco Giants games for three years (1958-1960) after the Giants departed New York. So good, complete with sound effects, that many thought Les was really at the game in SanFran!
We get it, AM radio is too much a part of American baseball fandom to be excised from the radio dial. So, give me a super-sized serving of Amplitude Modulation, please.
Bill Schaefer
SOURCES: Las Vegas Sun, 9/26/23, AP baseball writer, Mike Fitzpatrick; SABR, Red Barber, by Warren Corbett; SABR, Mel Allen, by Warren Corbett; Wikipedia, Red Barber, Russ Hodges, Ernie Harwell; Wikipedia, WMGM.
Subscribe to our website, Baseball History Comes Alive with over 1400 fully categorized baseball essays and photo galleries, now surpassing the one million hits mark with 1,115,000 hits and over 950 subscribers
I will greatly miss Cleveland AM broadcasts of they are ever taken away. I miss the late Herb Score (“it could be fair, it could be foul, it is!” …. “I don’t know about you, but this fellow has a lot of potential” …. “Alex Cole now in centerfield for the Indians replacing Otis Nixon {Cole had played the whole game}) Our Tom Hamilton is up for the HOF this summer, and deservedly so.
Thanks Cary…let’s hope he gets in. Here’s a nice pic of Tom Hamilton:https://www.baseballhistorycomesalive.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/1-radio-16.png
What a terrific article by Mr. Schaefer ! Sure stirred up some nostalgia for me. As a young sprout, I spent many a day {and night} listening to Bob Elson broadcasting WSox games on WCFL-1000. Having to move to SoCal was exciting in a lot of ways, but somewhat traumatic as well…i.e. moving away from all my schoolmates, Little League teammates, plus not being able to go to Comiskey Park anymore, and only being with-in AM range to listen to the *$&#^ Dodgers and Angels games. However, on the occasions that I did tune in to a Dodger game, I came to appreciate the excellence of the legendary Mr. Scully. I tried to sneak a listen to the WS games on my little transistor radio during school every chance I got. A bonus was if we had a teacher who was also baseball fanatic, who would suspend most {if not all} of that day’s lessons so we could listen to the game. You are so right Bill….for us senior citizens, listening to the game as we knew it; {when we first loved it as little kids}, is slowly fading away. It’s like sitting in front of a fireplace watching the slowly dying embers of a once a flaming blaze. Great essay, fellas. BHCA ROCKS !!!!
Thanks Tom. I know you’re not a Cub fan, but as a baseball fan I know you’d agree with me when I say it’s a sin what the Cubs have done. They’ve completely ruined their radio broadcasts, while taking a HOF broadcaster, Pat Hughes, and turning him into a cheap shill, with the most ridiculous revenue streams interrupting the esthetic flow of the game repeatedly, inning after inning…and I mean repeatedly! It’s nonending! It’s become almost impossible to listen to a Cubs radio broadcast the past few years. They’ve become “unlistenable,” if that’s a word. And every year it gets a little bit worse. It’s especially disturbing to me, a lifelong Cub fan who always carried a transisto, and who grew up first with Jack Quinlan and Lou Boudreau and later Vince Lloyd and Lou. Pat Hughes and Ron Santo were a lot of fun, too, but those days are sadly long gone. Thanks for the comment.
Thanks for putting all of those photos up. Most of them I never heard broadcast, but I’ve read so much about them and heard from friends about how Jimmy Dudley and Jack Graney or whoever were.
As a Giants fan in SF, I heard Russ Hodges almost run out of words describing what Willie Mays just did.
Lose AM radio? Never.
Agree, Gary. Yes, Pat Hughes is a Cubs legend. His enshrinement in Cooperstown is so well deserved. Yeah, all of the irritating endorsements and advertisements that interrupt an inning of play are, unfortunately, the norm now-a-days. During this year’s WS, FOX was totally ridiculous….pausing right in the middle of a half-inning to show a plug for “Capital” or “Verizon” or, etc. etc. Guess it’s because all of pro sports has gone more “corporate-financing dependent”. I wish that today’s younger generation could experience the baseball “shop-talk” chatter {that the announcers of a by-gone era engaged in} that we got to listen to years ago. Only a few today have that baseball “ad-lib” ability. Bob Costas and Bob Uecker are a couple that come to mind. On the South-side TV crew, Steve Stone and Jason Benetti are really good, but they will never make anybody forget Mel Allen or Jack Brickhouse. Q. what are your thoughts about your new manager ? I’ll bet they’re not very happy up in “Brew-town”…hahahaha. Thnx, Gary. Have a good week.
Thanks Tom. You know, I was totally shocked when I returned home yesterday from visiting the grandkids in Phoenix to hear the news. I had no inkling such a move was in the works. On top of that, I came to like David Ross. But unfortunately, the late season fold probably did him in. But why they went after Counsel?…I have no idea. Just on the surface, it doesn’t appear to me to be a good fit. But of course, I hope I’m wrong.
Now I wake up this morning to find that Jason Benetti is leaving the White Sox!
Brought back a lot of memories, Bill. I do think though that Les Keiter’s call was “he beat the ball, he beat the ball,” not the play. Les’ daughter Cindy did a one-woman show several years ago off Broadway and talked about Les’s NY career and her own
journey to become an actress. But she was born after Les’ NYC years that included Knicks broadcasts in the early 1960s. “Panicville!” was Les’s description for last couple of minutes of a close game. He then went to Philly where I think Cindy was born and then became a fxiture in Hawaii.
Thanks for checking in Lee!
Thanks, Cafry, Tom, John!
Very funny, Mr. S, with the Herb score quotes…he was electric on the mound before his injury-HOF written all over him.
You’re becoming quite eloquent, Tom, “Slowly dying embers of a once flaming blaze” BHCA is definitely rubbing off on you!
Gary Cohen, Ron Darling and Keith Hernandez are currently the best in the booth. The exchanges between Cohen and Darling are an education. Though they talk it up maybe a tad too much at times.
Love the pictures, Gary! Never knew what Giants broadcaster, Steve Ellis, looked like!
You snuck in, Lee, when I wasn’t looking! Thanks much for the comments. Interesting about his daughter and other career stops.
But, although “He beat the ball” makes more sense, Keiter definitely said “He beat the play!” Maybe someone has a tape.
Anyway, I’ll dig around and possibly find a definitive statement somewhere.
Best, Bill
Hey Lee,
Just came up with this from a David Halberstam article on Keiter:
“Keiter was a hit in New York, a connection to the Dodgers of Ebbets Field and the Giants of the Polo Grounds. He chronicled Mays, Cepeda and McCovey and developed memorable phrases. When Mays legged out an infield single, “He beat the ball! He beat the ball!”
This would seem to indicate you’re right and I’m wrong. Hate when that happens!
But I’ll keep looking to somehow achieve vindication.
Good job!
We forgive you Bill!
Herr Schaefer, Wow, thnx for the high praise and compliment, Bill. Was just trying to keep pace with “masters” such as yourself. Although I am not really that adept at producing literary content at a high level {I won’t win a Pulitzer any time soon}, I enjoy reading and responding to all of the articles that you and the other great BHCA contributors provide. {Keep the fireplace lit up, pal.}
Hey Tom – I think your literary skills are fine! How about putting something together about umpires…or growing up a Sox fan in Chicago? If it needs a little editing, that’s my job. Would love to have you as an occasional contributor!
Nice article which brought many memories to mind. Raised in the hinterlands of Pennsylvania I recall laying in bed summer nights listening to Mel Allen of the Yanks, Waite Hoyt of Cincinnati (He loved his Burger Beer), and Bob Prince of the Pirates. Later Ernie Harwell was a favorite. The only announcer I can stand presently is Bob Walk of the Pirates. Radio games now are full of ads, where the announcers ate last night, their golf games etc. everything except baseball. Never cared for Tom Hamilton-big homer. Mike Shannon of the Cards was super. It’s too bad they can’t clone Vin Scully for every team.
Thanks Kevin – you can read my opinion of today’s radio broadcasts above…like you, I’m not a fan…
AM radio transmission of baseball games had its minuses as well as pluses, but at least reception was free. This business of requiring subscriptions to listen to games reflects nothing but greed on the part of MLB autocrats.