Site icon Baseball History Comes Alive

The Man Who Replaced Lou Gehrig – Babe Dahlgren

Lou Gehrig consoles Babe Dahlgren

Click “Home” icon on left to see display of all my articles. Follow me on Twitter: @Livac2

 

A Sad Day In Baseball History

The Yankees won the game that day, but nobody cheered…

May 2, 1939 will always remain one of the saddest days in baseball history. Lou Gehrig took himself out of the Yankee line-up before a game at Detroit between the Tigers and the Yankees, and his 14-year, 2,130 consecutive games streak finally came to an end. Babe Dahlgren, the man who replaced the “iron Horse”, was stunned by the news, and needed some encouragement from Lou before he could take the field.

The Man Who Replaced Lou Gehrig:

Babe Dahlgren

Babe Dahlgren is shown with Lou Gehrig in the first photo before taking the field and officially ending Gehrig’s streak.

On that day Dahlgren had a homer and double in the Yankees’ 22-2 rout of the Tigers. He went on to hit 15 home runs and drive in 89 runs for the season. His career spanned 12 years and he hit .261 with 82 home runs and 569 RBIs. Dahlgren was known as a slick-fielding first baseman and was considered by many the best defensive first basemen of his era.

 In 1941, a vicious rumor was circulated that Dahlgren smoked marijuana. According to his grandson, Matt Dahlgren in his recent book about his grandfather, “Rumor in Town” it was started by Yankee manager Joe McCarthy. The rumor tarnished Dahlgren’s reputation around the major leagues, severely damaging his career. He was traded to eight different teams between 1940 and 1946 even though his defensive skills were extraordinary.
Babe Dahlgren with Yankee teammaed George Selkrik

After discovering the existence of the rumor in 1943, Dahlgren became the first major league baseball player to take a drug test for a non-performance enhancing drug. He did so voluntarily to discredit the rumors circulating at the time. The tests were all negative, refuting the charges of marijuana use. Dahlgren spent decades trying to uncover the source of the rumor and to clear his name, a crusade that was later picked up by his grandson, Matt Dahlgren who pinned it upon Joe McCarthy.

Babe Dahlgren shown with Red SOx teammates and roommate, Mel Almada

UPDATE: See the comments setion below for an explanation as to why McCarthy started this rumor about Babe Dahlgren.

-Gary Livacari

Thanks for reading my post. Hope you enjoyed it! Before you leave, I hope you’ll consider:

-Viewing the other posts in my blog. Click “Home” icon on left to see display of other posts.

-Following me on any one of my social networks.

-Sharing to your favorite social media

-Leaving a comment…I love interacting with my readers!

-Subscribing for automatic updates

Photo Credits: “Greats of the Game” by Ray Robinson; and The Boston Public Library Leslie Jones Collection.

Information from the Babe Dahlgren Wikipedia page and from “Rumor in Town,” by Matt Dahlgren.

Exit mobile version